Categories
Contact Us
Add: 5F, Building 3A, No.8 Xiyuanyi Road, West Lake Science Park, Hangzhou, China
Tel: +86-571-87858811
Mob: +8613616520351
E-mail: trade@qiyangtech.com
News
Home > News > Content
Wince VS Linux, Who Wins?
Jul 13, 2018

I would assume that Windows CE wins on tools and Linux wins on both cost and possibly performance. However this is just utter speculation. Does anyone have any facts or experience of the two?

Below is the good comparison I've ever seen:


Tools: Windows CE tools certainly are better than those provided by Linux, though the linux tools are certainly getting better.


Performance: Windows CE is real-time. Linux is not. The linux kernel is not designed for determinism at all. There are extensions that you can add to get sort-of real time, but CE beats it.


Cost: This is an area of great misunderstanding. My general experience is that CE is lower cost out of the box ($1k for Platform Builder and as low as $3 per device for a shipping runtime. "What?" you ask? "Linux is free." Well, not really so much, especially in the embedded arena. Yes, there are free distributions like Debian. But there are plenty of pieces that you might need that aren't in that free category. UI frameworks like QT, Java runtimes and media codecs just as a start. Also, most Linux distributions with a commercially-backed support system (e.g. MontaVista) are far from free.


Source Availability: Linux proponents may like to say that CE is a bad choice due to lack of source code. All I can say is that in over a decade of working with CE, half of which spent doing custom kernel and driver work for custom boards, I've only ever had need for source that didn't ship with CE (they ship a vast majority of it) once. I like having source too, but Microsoft provides support, so in the rare case you might think you need that source, you can get them to fix the problem (the one time we needed source, Microsoft provided a fix, and for free - which is their model under CE.


Does this mean that CE wins every time? No. I wouldn't suggest that at all. If you are a Linux shop and you have lots of Linux experience and code assets, you'd be foolish to run out and go CE. However, if you're coming into it from scratch CE usually has a lower TCO. Developers with Win32/C# experience are more prevalent and consequently less expensive. You also get a lot more "in the box" with CE than most other distributions, meaning faster time to market if you don't already have these things done in-house already.


WINCE supported by our TI AM335X :

TI 335X Development Board .jpg

Linux supported by our Freescale i.mx6:

Freescale imx6 SBC.jpg

  • Newsletter
  • Categories
  • Contact Us
    Add: 5F, Building 3A, No.8 Xiyuanyi Road, West Lake Science Park, Hangzhou, China
    Tel: +86-571-87858811
    Mob: +8613616520351
    E-mail: trade@qiyangtech.com
  • QR Code
  • Copyright © Zhejiang Qiyang Intelligent Technology Co.,Ltd All Rights Reserved.